Q. Find the integer solutions to \[ y^2 = x^3 – 2 \]

Answer

Work in the UFD \( \mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{-2}] \). Factor
\(y^2+2=(y+\sqrt{-2})(y-\sqrt{-2})=x^3\).
Any common divisor of \(y+\sqrt{-2}\) and \(y-\sqrt{-2}\) divides their difference \(2\sqrt{-2}\), hence divides 2. If 2 divided \(x^3\) then \(x\) is even, so \(y^2=x^3-2\equiv -2\equiv 6\pmod 8\), impossible. Thus \(\gcd(y+\sqrt{-2},y-\sqrt{-2})=1\). Since their product is a cube and the ring is a UFD, each factor is a cube:
\(y+\sqrt{-2}=(a+b\sqrt{-2})^3\) with \(a,b\in\mathbb{Z}\). Expanding gives
\(a^3-6ab^2=y\) and \(3a^2b-2b^3=1\).
Hence \(b\mid1\), so \(b=\pm1\). For \(b=1\) we get \(3a^2-2=1\), so \(a=\pm1\), yielding \(y=\mp5\) and \(x^3=y^2+2=27\), so \(x=3\). The case \(b=-1\) gives no integer \(a\).

Therefore the integer solutions are \((x,y)=(3,5)\) and \((3,-5)\).

Detailed Explanation

We want to find all integer solutions to the classic Mordell equation. We will solve this using factorization in the ring \( \mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{-2}] \), which acts as a Unique Factorization Domain.

\[ y^2 = x^3 – 2 \]

First, rewrite the equation as \( y^2 + 2 = x^3 \). We factor the left side over \( \mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{-2}] \) to get \( (y + \sqrt{-2})(y – \sqrt{-2}) = x^3 \).

We must determine the parity of \( y \). If \( y \) were an even integer, then \( y^2 \equiv 0 \pmod{4} \), meaning \( x^3 = y^2 + 2 \equiv 2 \pmod{4} \). However, no perfect integer cube can be congruent to \( 2 \pmod{4} \), as cubes are strictly \( 0, 1, \) or \( 3 \pmod{4} \). Therefore, \( y \) must be an odd integer. Consequently, \( x^3 \) is odd, making \( x \) odd as well.

Next, we check for common divisors of the factors \( (y + \sqrt{-2}) \) and \( (y – \sqrt{-2}) \). Any common divisor \( d \) must divide their geometric difference, which is \( 2\sqrt{-2} \). The norm of \( 2\sqrt{-2} \) is \( 8 \), while the norm of \( y \pm \sqrt{-2} \) is \( x^3 \), which is odd. Because they share no common prime factors, \( (y + \sqrt{-2}) \) and \( (y – \sqrt{-2}) \) are coprime.

Because their product is a perfect cube and they are coprime in a Unique Factorization Domain, each individual factor must itself be a perfect cube multiplied by a unit. The only units in \( \mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{-2}] \) are \( 1 \) and \( -1 \), both of which are themselves perfect cubes. Therefore, we can confidently write \( y + \sqrt{-2} = (a + b\sqrt{-2})^3 \) for some integers \( a \) and \( b \).

Expanding the right side using the binomial theorem gives \( a^3 + 3a^2 b \sqrt{-2} + 3a(b\sqrt{-2})^2 + (b\sqrt{-2})^3 \), which algebraically simplifies to \( (a^3 – 6 a b^2) + (3 a^2 b – 2 b^3)\sqrt{-2} \).

By equating the imaginary parts of both sides, we get \( 1 = 3 a^2 b – 2 b^3 \), which factors as \( 1 = b(3 a^2 – 2 b^2) \). Since \( a \) and \( b \) are integers, \( b \) must be a factor of \( 1 \). This leaves exactly two possibilities: \( b = 1 \) or \( b = -1 \).

If \( b = -1 \), the equation becomes \( 1 = -1(3 a^2 – 2) = 2 – 3 a^2 \), implying \( 3 a^2 = 1 \), which yields no integer solution for \( a \).

If \( b = 1 \), the equation becomes \( 1 = 1(3 a^2 – 2) \), meaning \( 3 a^2 = 3 \), which cleanly simplifies to \( a^2 = 1 \). This gives two valid roots: \( a = 1 \) or \( a = -1 \).

Now, we equate the real parts, yielding \( y = a^3 – 6 a b^2 = a(a^2 – 6 b^2) \). Substituting \( b = 1 \) and \( a = 1 \), we get \( y = 1(1 – 6) = -5 \). Substituting \( b = 1 \) and \( a = -1 \), we get \( y = -1(1 – 6) = 5 \). Thus, \( y = 5 \) or \( y = -5 \).

Substitute \( y = \pm 5 \) back into the original equation to find \( x \). This gives \( 25 = x^3 – 2 \), which implies \( x^3 = 27 \), leading directly to \( x = 3 \). The only valid integer solutions \( (x, y) \) are \( (3, 5) \) and \( (3, -5) \).

See full solution
image
Stuck on this problem? Try our AI homework help tools today!
AI homework helper

Geometry FAQs

What are the integer solutions of \(y^{2}=x^{3}-2\)?

The only integer solutions are \( (x,y)=(3,\pm 5) \). This is a classical result obtained by elliptic-curve methods \( \) (one checks these work and then rules out any other integer points).

Why can’t \(x\) be negative?

If \(x<0\) then \(x^{3}-2<0\), but \(y^{2}\ge0\). So no negative \(x\) can produce an integer \(y\). Thus any integer solution must have \(x\ge 2\).

How do you prove there are no other integer solutions?

One proves it using elliptic-curve theory: \(E:\;y^{2}=x^{3}-2\) is an elliptic curve of rank \(1\) with generator \((3,5)\) and trivial torsion; combining descent/Lutz–Nagell and height arguments (or explicit Baker bounds) shows no other integer points exist.

Is \(y^{2}=x^{3}-2\) an elliptic curve and what does that imply?

Yes; it’s a smooth cubic (genus 1). Mordell’s theorem implies finitely generated rational points. Here the rational group has positive rank, so infinitely many rational points but only finitely many integral points.

Can simple modular arithmetic rule out other solutions?.

Modular reductions (mod small primes) help exclude many residue classes, but they don’t by themselves complete the proof. They are a useful first step combined with deeper elliptic-curve or Diophantine methods.

Are there infinitely many rational solutions?.

Are there infinitely many rational solutions?.

Which theorems/tools are standard to solve this type of equation?

Typical tools: Mordell’s theorem, Lutz–Nagell for torsion, descent on elliptic curves, Baker’s bounds on linear forms in logarithms (effective finiteness), and computational packages (Sage, mwrank, PARI/GP) to complete explicit checking.

How can I check this computationally?

Use Sage, PARI/GP, or Magma: compute the curve \(E: y^2 = x^3 - 2\), its rank and generators (mwrank), then enumerate integral points. In Sage: EllipticCurve([0,0,0,0,-2]).integral_points() will return \((3,\pm5)\).
Master math with our advanced tools
Try finance, econ, and accounting AI
image
252,312+ customers tried
Analytical, General, Biochemistry, etc.
top
Upgrade to Edubrain Premium
Unlimited help across all subjects
$16
$3.99
/week
Core benefits:
  • ok Unlimited AI homework help
  • ok A+ quality answers
  • ok Faster responses, no limits
Tools:
  • ok Notes generator
  • ok Diagram generator
  • ok AI detector and humanizer
Extras:
  • ok Ad-free experience
  • ok Share responses with others
  • ok Advanced reasoning
expert
Expert-level help at discounted prices
Cancel anytime
Star
4.6Trusted by 14,623 students
🚀 Upgrade Plan
You’ve reached the free limit of 5 slides.
To generate a full presentation, please subscribe.
Unlock with subscription:
  • ok Unlimited slide generation for presentations
  • ok AI-designed, well-structured slide content
  • ok Faster workflow for bigger decks
-
Plus, get unlimited access to:
  • ok Diagram Generator, Flashcard Maker, Notes Generator, Research Assistant, Answer Generator, AI Homework Helper & AI Detector
  • ok Discounted designer expert help
Star
4.6Trusted by 14,623 students