Q. Find the integer solutions to \[ y^2 = x^3 – 2 \]
Answer
Work in the UFD \( \mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{-2}] \). Factor
\(y^2+2=(y+\sqrt{-2})(y-\sqrt{-2})=x^3\).
Any common divisor of \(y+\sqrt{-2}\) and \(y-\sqrt{-2}\) divides their difference \(2\sqrt{-2}\), hence divides 2. If 2 divided \(x^3\) then \(x\) is even, so \(y^2=x^3-2\equiv -2\equiv 6\pmod 8\), impossible. Thus \(\gcd(y+\sqrt{-2},y-\sqrt{-2})=1\). Since their product is a cube and the ring is a UFD, each factor is a cube:
\(y+\sqrt{-2}=(a+b\sqrt{-2})^3\) with \(a,b\in\mathbb{Z}\). Expanding gives
\(a^3-6ab^2=y\) and \(3a^2b-2b^3=1\).
Hence \(b\mid1\), so \(b=\pm1\). For \(b=1\) we get \(3a^2-2=1\), so \(a=\pm1\), yielding \(y=\mp5\) and \(x^3=y^2+2=27\), so \(x=3\). The case \(b=-1\) gives no integer \(a\).
Therefore the integer solutions are \((x,y)=(3,5)\) and \((3,-5)\).
Detailed Explanation
We want to find all integer solutions to the classic Mordell equation. We will solve this using factorization in the ring \( \mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{-2}] \), which acts as a Unique Factorization Domain.
\[ y^2 = x^3 – 2 \]
First, rewrite the equation as \( y^2 + 2 = x^3 \). We factor the left side over \( \mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{-2}] \) to get \( (y + \sqrt{-2})(y – \sqrt{-2}) = x^3 \).
We must determine the parity of \( y \). If \( y \) were an even integer, then \( y^2 \equiv 0 \pmod{4} \), meaning \( x^3 = y^2 + 2 \equiv 2 \pmod{4} \). However, no perfect integer cube can be congruent to \( 2 \pmod{4} \), as cubes are strictly \( 0, 1, \) or \( 3 \pmod{4} \). Therefore, \( y \) must be an odd integer. Consequently, \( x^3 \) is odd, making \( x \) odd as well.
Next, we check for common divisors of the factors \( (y + \sqrt{-2}) \) and \( (y – \sqrt{-2}) \). Any common divisor \( d \) must divide their geometric difference, which is \( 2\sqrt{-2} \). The norm of \( 2\sqrt{-2} \) is \( 8 \), while the norm of \( y \pm \sqrt{-2} \) is \( x^3 \), which is odd. Because they share no common prime factors, \( (y + \sqrt{-2}) \) and \( (y – \sqrt{-2}) \) are coprime.
Because their product is a perfect cube and they are coprime in a Unique Factorization Domain, each individual factor must itself be a perfect cube multiplied by a unit. The only units in \( \mathbb{Z}[\sqrt{-2}] \) are \( 1 \) and \( -1 \), both of which are themselves perfect cubes. Therefore, we can confidently write \( y + \sqrt{-2} = (a + b\sqrt{-2})^3 \) for some integers \( a \) and \( b \).
Expanding the right side using the binomial theorem gives \( a^3 + 3a^2 b \sqrt{-2} + 3a(b\sqrt{-2})^2 + (b\sqrt{-2})^3 \), which algebraically simplifies to \( (a^3 – 6 a b^2) + (3 a^2 b – 2 b^3)\sqrt{-2} \).
By equating the imaginary parts of both sides, we get \( 1 = 3 a^2 b – 2 b^3 \), which factors as \( 1 = b(3 a^2 – 2 b^2) \). Since \( a \) and \( b \) are integers, \( b \) must be a factor of \( 1 \). This leaves exactly two possibilities: \( b = 1 \) or \( b = -1 \).
If \( b = -1 \), the equation becomes \( 1 = -1(3 a^2 – 2) = 2 – 3 a^2 \), implying \( 3 a^2 = 1 \), which yields no integer solution for \( a \).
If \( b = 1 \), the equation becomes \( 1 = 1(3 a^2 – 2) \), meaning \( 3 a^2 = 3 \), which cleanly simplifies to \( a^2 = 1 \). This gives two valid roots: \( a = 1 \) or \( a = -1 \).
Now, we equate the real parts, yielding \( y = a^3 – 6 a b^2 = a(a^2 – 6 b^2) \). Substituting \( b = 1 \) and \( a = 1 \), we get \( y = 1(1 – 6) = -5 \). Substituting \( b = 1 \) and \( a = -1 \), we get \( y = -1(1 – 6) = 5 \). Thus, \( y = 5 \) or \( y = -5 \).
Substitute \( y = \pm 5 \) back into the original equation to find \( x \). This gives \( 25 = x^3 – 2 \), which implies \( x^3 = 27 \), leading directly to \( x = 3 \). The only valid integer solutions \( (x, y) \) are \( (3, 5) \) and \( (3, -5) \).
Geometry FAQs
What are the integer solutions of \(y^{2}=x^{3}-2\)?
Why can’t \(x\) be negative?
How do you prove there are no other integer solutions?
Is \(y^{2}=x^{3}-2\) an elliptic curve and what does that imply?
Can simple modular arithmetic rule out other solutions?.
Are there infinitely many rational solutions?.
Which theorems/tools are standard to solve this type of equation?
How can I check this computationally?
Try finance, econ, and accounting AI
Analytical, General, Biochemistry, etc.